Cast
Anthony Tony Rita Ethel Lee Broadway Diva Sperm Bank Receptionist Priest Kelsey Michael Bob Trevor Gina Peter Aaron Beau Brian Garrett Gavin Pascual Daryl Maria Robert Luke Joey Christopher Suzie Carly Natalie Singing Nazi Singing Nun Phantom Cowboy Soloist Bertha Jolene Singing Cat Singing Cat Nicole / Claudette, voice acting Candi (Voice) Voice Dancer Dancer Dancer Dancer Dancer Dancer Dancer Dancer Dancer Dancer Dancer Steven / Tap Dancer Ricky / Tap Dancer Andy / Tap Dancer Jason / Tap Dancer Brad / Tap Dancer Voice Dancer Amber Casey / Tap Dancer Church Goer, not listed in creditsа Rachel, not listed in creditsа Sperm Bank Customer, not listed in credits Cafe Patron, not listed in credits Church goer, not listed in credits Theatre Patron, not listed in creditsа Church Goer, not listed in credits Choir Singer, not listed in credits Church Goer, not listed in creditsа Theatre Patron, not listed in credits Sperm Bank Customer, not listed in credits Rehearsal Pianist, not listed in credits Party Guest, not listed in creditsа Theatre Patron / Church Goer / Party Guest, not listed in credits Theatre Patron, not listed in creditsа Sperm Bank Customer, not listed in credits Theatre Patron, not listed in credits Waiter, not listed in credits Cafe Patron, not listed in credits Party Guest, not listed in credits Party Guest, not listed in credits Theatre Patron, not listed in credits Choir Singer, not listed in creditsа Pepper, not listed in creditsа Theatre Patron, not listed in credits Choir Singer, not listed in creditsа Theatre Patron, not listed in credits
Sperm Bank Customer, not listed in credits