Herschel Mayall Filmography
- Actor (99 credits)
- Come to Dinner (1934) Oliver Jurgen
- The Side Show Mystery (1932)
- Hey, Pop! (1932) Contest judge, not listed in credits
- Big Town (1932) Banker
- The Cole Case (1932)
- His Woman (1931) Mrs. Morrisey
- The Antique Shop (1931) Proprietor
- The Royal Family of Broadway (1930) Doctor
- Fast and Loose (1930) Judge Summers
- The Great Power (1929) John Power
- After Marriage (1925) James Morgan
- Alimony (1924) Blake
- Wild Bill Hickok (1923) Gambler
- In the Days of Daniel Boone (1923) General Braddock
- Itching Palms (1923) Jerry's Father
- Calvert's Valley (1922) Judge Rymal
- The Yellow Stain (1922) Dr. Brown
- Thirty Days (1922) Giacomo Polenta
- Arabian Love (1922) The Sheik
- Extra! Extra! (1922) Edward Fletcher
- Smiles Are Trumps (1922) James Manning
- Straight from the Shoulder (1921) Joseph Martin
- Three Word Brand (1921) Carroll, not listed in credits
- The Blushing Bride (1921) Lord Lansmere
- The Queen of Sheba (1921) Menton
- The Beautiful Gambler (1921) Judge Rand
- Daredevil Jack (1920) Leonard Billigns
- Kismet (1920) Jawan
- The Sleeping Lion (1919) Durant
- Todd of the Times (1919) Harrison G. Monroe
- The Divorce Trap (1919) Daniel Drake
- A Man in the Open (1919) Trevor
- The Money Corral (1919) Carl Bruler
- Wings of the Morning (1919) Col. Costabel
- Bonds of Honor (1919) Paul Berkowitz
- The Silver Girl (1919) Gilman Parton
- Wedlock (1918) George Osborne
- Shackled (1918) Henry Hartman
- Carmen of the Klondike (1918) «Silk» McDonald
- Treasure Island (1918) Prologue Player
- Honor's Cross (1918) Thomas Dolan
- Maid o' the Storm (1918) Abe Strohman
- Patriotism (1918) Sidney Carson
- The Heart of Rachael (1918) Clarence Breckenridge
- The One Woman (1918) Mark Overman
- A Tale of Two Cities (1917) Jacques Defarge
- Madame Du Barry (1917) Jean DuBarry
- The Babes in the Woods (1917) John Hamilton
- The Rose of Blood (1917) Koliensky
- Cleopatra (1917) Ventidius
- High Finance (1917) Jonathan Platt
- The Island of Desire (1917) Henry Sayres
- Some Boy (1917) William Johnson
- The Aryan (1916) Chip Emmett
- Sins of Her Parent (1916) Jim McNeil
- Civilization (1916) The King of Wredpryd
- The Road to Love (1916) Sidi Malik
- The Sorrows of Love (1916) Prince Candoni
- The Beast (1916) David Manning
- The Renegade (1915) Robert Graves - the Renegade
- The Mill by the Zuyder Zee (1915) Captain Rondez
- The Man from Oregon (1915) William Landers
- The Toast of Death (1915) Yar Khan
- A Modern Noble (1915) Count von Hoffmann
- The Spirit of the Bell (1915) Padre
- On the Night Stage (1915) Handsome Jack Malone
- The Soul of Phyra (1915) Captain Brenner
- Keno Bates, Liar (1915) Wind River
- The Forbidden Adventure (1915) John Robbins
- Divorce (1914) Robert White
- Love vs Duty (1914) Dan Kelly
- The Sheriff's Sister (1914)
- The Sheriff of Bisbee (1914)
- The Informer (1914) Michael
- The Fortunes of War (1914) Don José Hermanos
- The Wharf Rats (1914) Jim Reed
- Jim Regan's Last Raid (1914) Jim Regan
- A Romance of Old Holland (1914) Captain Kruger
- The Silent Messenger (1914) Pietro Giovanti
- The Typhoon (1914)
- The Wrath of the Gods (1914)
- In the Sage Brush Country (1914) Frank Wilding
- The Right to Die (1914) David Walters
- In the Days of the Padres (1914)
- The Voice at the Telephone (1914) Spike Kennedy
- The City of Darkness (1914) Horgan - the Ward Boss
- The Bargain (1914) Gambler, not listed in credits
- Star of the North (1914)
- From Out of the Dregs (1914) Amos Barry - Tom's Father
- The Battle of Gettysburg (1913)
- From Out the Storm (1913) Rusty Hogan
- The Claim Jumper (1913) Jim Rankin, Miner
- The Great Sacrifice (1913) Silas Green
- Days of '49 (1913)
- Under Two Flags (1912) Bertie Cecil
- What the Bell Tolled (1912) The Doctor
- The Dead Pay (1912) Capt. King
- When Lee Surrenders (1912)
- The Convict's Return (1912) Bill Downing
